Searching over 5,500,000 cases.


searching
Buy This Entire Record For $7.95

Download the entire decision to receive the complete text, official citation,
docket number, dissents and concurrences, and footnotes for this case.

Learn more about what you receive with purchase of this case.

Below v. Yokohama Tire Corp.

United States District Court, W.D. Wisconsin

March 3, 2017

JOSHUA J. BELOW, DEBRA BELOW, CHARLIE ELIZABETH BELOW, PATRICK JOSHUA BELOW, STAR BLUE BELOW-KOPF and DEAN HEALTH PLAN, INC., Plaintiffs,
v.
YOKOHAMA TIRE CORPORATION, YOKOHAMA CORPORATION OF AMERICA, YOKOHAMA CORPORATION OF NORTH AMERICA, YOKOHAMA TIRE MANUFACTURING VIRGINIA, LLC, and YOKOHAMA RUBBER COMPANY, LTD., Defendants. Plaintiff's Designations Defendants' Objections Court Ruling Plaintiff's Designations Defendants' Objections Court Ruling Plaintiff's Designations Defendants' Objections Court Ruling

          ORDER

          WILLIAM M. CONLEY District Judge

         The court rules as follows on the objections to deposition designations.

         Thomas Kenny

Plaintiff's Designations

Defendants' Objections

Court Ruling

32:12-32:25

32:12-14, 32:16, 32:18-20 32:22-23 FRE 402-302, Relevance, Misleading, Confusing to jury

OVERRULED RESERVED

34:14-35:8

34:14-16, 34:18, 34:20, 34:22, 34:24-25 FRE 402-302, Relevance, Misleading, Confusing to jury

SUSTAINED, and lines 35:2-8 are STRUCK

36:16-39:4 39:9-15

36:16-19, 37:3, 37:21-23, 37:25-38:2, 38:7-11, 38:15-17, 38:20-21 38:23-25, 39:9-11 FRE 402-302, Relevance, Misleading, Lack of foundation

OVERRULED

41:21-42:10

41:21-25, 42:4-7 FRE 402-302, Relevance, Misleading, Lack of foundation

Designation withdrawn

42:16-42:19

FRE 402-302, Relevance, Misleading, Lack of foundation

Objections withdrawn

43:12-20

43:12-16, 43:18-19 FRE 402-302, Relevance, Misleading, Lack of foundation

Objections withdrawn

48:14-19

48:14-17 FRE 402-302. Relevance, Vague, Misleading, Lack of foundation

OVERRULED

50:3-13

50:3-4, 50:6-7, 50:9-10 50:12 FRE 402-302, Relevance, Misleading, Lack of foundation

Objections withdrawn

57:17-58:17

57:17-20 FRE 402-302, Relevance, Confusion, Lack of foundation, Speculation

OVERRULED

60:10-61:14

60:10 61:1-4 FRE 402-302, Relevance, Lack of foundation, Nonsensical

SUSTAINED, and lines 61:6-9 are STRUCK

94:8-97:24

94:8-12, 94:13-16, 95:6-7, 96:1-4, 97:8-9 FRE 402-302, Relevance, Argumentative

RESERVED

105:22-106:7

105:22-25 FRE 402-302, Misleading, Argumentative, Vague, Ambiguous

RESERVED

132:13-133:7

132:10-12; 132:13-14, 132:23-24, 133:1-3 FRE 402-302, Relevance, Argumentative, Speculation, Incomplete Hypothetical, Nonsensical question

SUSTAINED

140:5-18

140:5-6, 140:7-12 FRE 402-302, Lack of foundation, Argumentative, Assumes facts not in evidence

OVERRULED

153:23-154:2

153:23-25 FRE 402-302, Relevance, Confusing, Nonsensical question

Designation withdrawn

         Chris Haefner

Plaintiff's Designations
Defendants' Objections
Court Ruling
13:10-12
Relevance, Lack of foundation, Speculation, etc.
SUSTAINED
13:20
Relevance, Lack of foundation, Speculation, etc
SUSTAINED
32:14-23
, Speculation
OVERRULED
33:2
FRE 402-302, Speculation
OVERRULED
33:5-6
Relevance, Lack of foundation, Speculation
OVERRULED
33:8-10
FRE 402-302, Relevance, Lack of foundation, Speculation
SUSTAINED

         Chris Jessen

Plaintiff's Designations
Defendants' Objections
Court Ruling
16:9-13
Leading, Legal conclusion, Speculation, Lack of foundation
SUSTAINED

         Vince Brandtner

Plaintiff's Designations
Defendants' Objections
Court Ruling
25:15-20

FRE 402-302, Relevance, Prejudicial, Misleading

OVERRULED

31:13-32:3

31:13-16

31:21-24

Speculation, Misstates evidence, FRE 402-403, Relevance

SUSTAINED OVERRULED

33:16-35:16

33:16-18

OVERRULED


Buy This Entire Record For $7.95

Download the entire decision to receive the complete text, official citation,
docket number, dissents and concurrences, and footnotes for this case.

Learn more about what you receive with purchase of this case.