Searching over 5,500,000 cases.


searching
Buy This Entire Record For $7.95

Download the entire decision to receive the complete text, official citation,
docket number, dissents and concurrences, and footnotes for this case.

Learn more about what you receive with purchase of this case.

DSM IP Assets, B.V. v. Lallemand Specialties, Inc.

United States District Court, W.D. Wisconsin

May 3, 2018

DSM IP ASSETS, B.V. & DSM BIO-BASED PRODUCTS & SERVICES, B.V., Plaintiffs and Counter-Defendants
v.
LALLEMAND SPECIALTIES, INC. & MASCOMA LLC, Defendants and Counterclaimants. DSM's Lallemand's Court Ruling Lallemand's DSM's DSM's Court

          ORDER

          WILLIAM M. CONLEY DISTRICT JUDGE.

         On the parties' deposition designations, counter-designations and objections as to Aaron Argyros, the court rules as follows:

DSM's
Lallemand's
Court Ruling
Lallemand's
DSM's
DSM's
Court

Designations

Objections

Counter-Designations

Objections to Lallemand's Counter-Designations

Counter Designations

Ruling

14:15-15:4

Strike 14:21-22; 15:1.

16:16-17:10

Strike 16:16-17.

38:11-39:9

Incomplete (FRE 106); Prejudicial/Confusing/ Misleading (FRE 403)

Overruled.

38:8-10 39:10-12 39:22-40:21

39:22-40:21: Beyond the scope of initial designation; hearsay (FRE 802)

Overruled.

95:5-105:11

Includes Attorney Objections

(FRE 611(a))

Sustain: 95:81; 96:3, 13, 19; 97:16-22; 98:1-8; 100:2; 101:11-22; 102:1-7, 16-22; 103:1-22; 104:1-3. Overruled as to remainder.

94:21-95:4

118:16-

Lack of Foundation

Overruled.

116:15-117:2

118:18

(FRE 102-105); Irrelevant (FRE 402); Prejudicial/Confusing/ Misleading (FRE 403);

Lack of Personal Knowledge (FRE 602); Hearsay (FRE 802); Authenticity

(FRE 901);

Includes Attorney Objections

(FRE 611(a))

119:13-122:12

Lack of Foundation

(FRE 102-105);

Sustain: 120:4, 12; 121:11-22; 122:1-22; also delete 123:1. Overruled as to remainder.

122:13-18 122:20-123:1

123:22-130:8

Irrelevant (FRE 402); Prejudicial/Confusing/ Misleading (FRE 403); Lack of Personal Knowledge (FRE 602); Hearsay (FRE 802); Authenticity

(FRE 901);

Includes Attorney Objections

(FRE 611(a))

Sustain: 123:1; 124:1-24; 125:1-130:8; Overruled as to remainder.

131:12-140:14

Irrelevant (FRE 402); Prejudicial/Confusing/ Misleading (FRE 403); Hearsay (FRE 802); Includes Attorney Objections

(FRE 611(a))

Sustain: 132:7, 11-22; 133:1-3; 134:8, 22; 135:8; 136:2-5, 11-13, 20; 137:8, 13, 20; 138:9, 16-22; 139:1-3, 19; 140:6, 22. Overruled as to remainder.

140:18-145:22

Lack of Foundation

(FRE 102-105); Irrelevant (FRE 402); Prejudicial/Confusing/ Misleading (FRE 403); Lack of Personal Knowledge (FRE 602); Hearsay (FRE 802); Authenticity

(FRE 901);

Includes Attorney Objections

(FRE 611(a))

Sustain: 141:1, 19; 142:15, 22; 143:7, 16, 19; 144:3, 16-22; 145:1-22.

146:6-146:10

Lack of Foundation

(FRE 102-105); Irrelevant (FRE 402); Prejudicial/Confusing/ Misleading (FRE 403); Lack of Personal

Knowledge (FRE 602); Hearsay (FRE 802)

Sustain.

147:9-147:17

Lack of Foundation

(FRE 102-105); Irrelevant (FRE 402); Prejudicial/Confusing/ Misleading (FRE 403); Lack of Personal Knowledge (FRE 602); Hearsay (FRE 802)

Sustain.

148:8-149:8

Lack of Foundation

(FRE 102-105); Irrelevant (FRE 402); Prejudicial/Confusing/ Misleading (FRE 403); Lack of Personal Knowledge (FRE 602); Hearsay (FRE 802); Includes Attorney Objections

(FRE 611(a))

Sustain.

149:18-150:6

Lack of Foundation

(FRE 102-105); Irrelevant (FRE 402); Prejudicial/Confusing/ Misleading (FRE 403); Lack of Personal Knowledge (FRE 602); Hearsay (FRE 802)

Overruled.

150:10-155:9

Lack of Foundation

(FRE 102-105);

Prejudicial/Confusing/ Misleading (FRE 403); Lack of Personal Knowledge (FRE 602); Hearsay (FRE 802); Includes Attorney Objections

(FRE 611(a))

Sustain: 151:9-21; 152:16; 153:1, 7; 154:1, 4, 22; 155:1-9. Overruled as to remainder.

155:13-164:1

Includes Attorney Objections

(FRE 611(a))

Sustain: 156:4l9; 158:7 (after word “presentation”) to 11, 17; 159:6, 16; 160:1-10, 16; 161:2-22; 162:3, 6; 163:4-13.

Exhibit 5 (PTX 486)

Lack of Foundation (FRE 102-105);

Irrelevant (FRE 402); Prejudicial/Confusing/Misleading

(FRE 403);

Lack of Personal Knowledge

(FRE 602);

Hearsay (FRE 802); Authenticity (FRE 901)

Overruled.

Exhibit 6 (PTX 240)

Objection withdrawn

Exhibit 7 (PTX 241)

Lack of Foundation (FRE 102-105);

Irrelevant (FRE 402); Prejudicial/Confusing/Misleading

(FRE 403);

Lack of Personal Knowledge

(FRE 602);

Hearsay (FRE 802); Authenticity

(FRE 901)

Overruled.

Exhibit 8 (PTX 242)

Lack of Foundation (FRE 102-105);

Irrelevant (FRE 402); Prejudicial/Confusing/Misleading

(FRE 403);

Lack of Personal Knowledge

(FRE 602);

Hearsay (FRE 802); Authenticity

(FRE 901)

Reserved.

Exhibit 9 (PTX 243)

Lack of Foundation (FRE 102-105);

Prejudicial/Confusing/Misleading

(FRE 403);

Lack of Personal Knowledge

(FRE 602); Hearsay (FRE 802)

Overruled.


Buy This Entire Record For $7.95

Download the entire decision to receive the complete text, official citation,
docket number, dissents and concurrences, and footnotes for this case.

Learn more about what you receive with purchase of this case.